Subdomain 1.2: Understand and apply security concepts
1.A healthcare provider uses a third-party billing service that processes patient medical records. An audit reveals that the service stores data on servers accessible over the public internet without encryption, and a recent breach exposed patient data. Which security pillar was MOST directly violated?
- A.Confidentiality
- B.Integrity
- C.Availability
- D.Nonrepudiation
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A — Confidentiality
- A. Correct. Confidentiality ensures that sensitive information is accessible only to authorized parties. The lack of encryption and exposure of patient data directly violates this pillar, as the breach resulted in unauthorized disclosure.
- B. Incorrect. Integrity protects data from unauthorized modification or destruction. The scenario focuses on unauthorized access and exposure, not on data being altered.
- C. Incorrect. Availability ensures systems and data are accessible when needed. Although the servers were accessible over the internet, the primary issue is unauthorized disclosure, not loss of access.
- D. Incorrect. Nonrepudiation ensures actions or transactions cannot be denied, typically through logs or signatures. The breach and lack of encryption relate to data secrecy, not proof of origin or denial.